Donor Stewardship: Use Storytelling to Show Donor Impact
May 21, 2025
Embedded Files
As a journalist, I was trained to earn the reader’s attention fast. If the first few sentences don’t spark emotion, the reader will bail.
That same principle applies to donor stewardship and donor impact reports. If your donor thank-you message doesn’t help them visualize their impact, donors won’t stay engaged.
Would this message make you feel warm and fuzzy as a donor?
“Thank you for your generous donation and for helping everyone in our community live longer, healthier lives.”
It’s well-meaning. It’s positive. But it’s too broad to land emotionally. I mean, how can a donor possibly feel a connection to "everyone"?
Show How The Donor Changes One Life
When donors can picture the impact they made, they feel more connected, and more likely to give again.
That kind of emotional donor engagement starts with one story. One life. One moment of healing.
With that in mind, let’s rework that well-meaning donor message by focusing on one person—not everyone.
“Thanks to your gift, Emily didn’t lose her hair, or her confidence, while fighting breast cancer. Your generosity provided cold cap therapy, a scalp cooling system that prevents hair loss during chemotherapy. For Emily, it meant holding onto a sense of normalcy during one of the hardest times of her life."
Donor Stewardship Tip: Keep a Tight Focus
Let’s look at how we can sharpen a few common healthcare nonprofit fundraising messages to create stronger emotional connection and support your donor stewardship strategy.
Before: Generic statement about emergency care
“Your gift helps improve emergency care across our entire hospital system.”
After: The donor becomes the hero
“Because of your generosity, Joe survived a stroke and got back on his feet. He was diagnosed within minutes using our new CT scanner, then started rehab right away. Today, he’s walking, talking, and back to reading bedtime stories to his grandkids.”
Before: Impersonal description of robotic technology
“Robot-assisted surgeries advance surgeons’ capabilities, allowing them to deliver high quality treatment to patients who previously would have had to travel out of the county for such surgical care.”
After: The donor has transformed Ronda's life
“Your gift made robotic-assisted spine surgery possible for Ronda, close to home. It relieved pressure on her spinal nerves with pinpoint precision. Today, she’s back to tending the garden she loves and living with the freedom she thought she’d lost forever.”
When donors can clearly picture the person they helped, they feel emotionally invested and want to keep giving to support your mission.
That’s how strong donor stewardship messaging drives long-term support, and why storytelling is a key part of every smart donor stewardship plan.
Get New Donor Engagement Tips Each Week
Subscribe to Nonprofit Mensa's email newsletter.
You'll receive practical, road-tested strategies for:
Donor engagement and stewardship
Grateful patient programs
Mid-level donor cultivation
Healthcare fundraising best practices
Donor messaging makeovers
Employee giving campaigns
And more!
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse