7 Thank-You Email Mistakes that Sabotage Donor Engagement

June 25, 2025

The average donor retention rate dropped to nearly 43% in 2024, but first-time donor retention rates are even worse.

Less than 20% of first-time donors gave again the following year, meaning nearly 80% of your new donors won’t come back, according to the Fundraising Effectiveness Project report.

You can boost first-time donor retention with one simple action: send timely, personalized thank-you emails to donors.

Donor thank-you emails consistently outperform other nonprofit messages. While the average open rate for nonprofit emails is about 29%, open rates for thank-you emails can be much higher, providing a unique engagement opportunity that doesn't happen too often.

7 Donor Thank-You Email Mistakes to Avoid

Donors who feel genuinely appreciated give more and stick around longer. In fact, 90% of donors say that a thank-you letter influences whether they'll donate again.

This moment is your chance to deepen the relationship, reinforce their impact, and inspire them to stay connected. But too often, nonprofits miss the mark.

Here are 7 mistakes we make when thanking donors—and how to fix them.

❌ Mistake #1: Treating the Receipt Like a Donor Thank-You Email

An automated receipt is a compliance document, not a donation thank-you email.

Send donors a separate, personalized thank-you email within 48 hours. Donors who receive prompt, meaningful thank-you emails are more likely to give again.

Use a hospital leader as the sender, like the CEO or a physician leader, rather than a foundation executive. Donors give to help patients and their families. Your sender and thank-you message should reflect that.

❌ Mistake #2: Beginning the Thank-You Letter with “Dear Friend”

Personalized donor thank-you emails can double the likelihood of securing a second gift, so be sure to use the donor's name and reference the fund or campaign they supported.

❌ Mistake #3: Forgetting the Emotion That Drives Giving

Storytelling delivers the joy, hope, and transformation donors crave. Anchor your donor thank-you email in a real, emotionally resonant story.

It doesn't have to be heavy or tragic. Uplifting stories, like a therapy dog comforting children before surgery or a cancer survivor celebrating her final chemotherapy treatment, can be powerful ways to show impact.

❌ Mistake #4: Treating the Thank-You Email as if It's the End of the Donor Journey

A one-time donation thank-you email isn’t enough to build lasting loyalty.

Most donor drop-off happens in the first 90 days. Use your donor thank-you email or letter as the launch point for a simple, structured 90-day new donor welcome series that builds trust, communicates impact, and builds toward loyal giving. (Borrow from this Grateful Patient welcome series I recommend.)

Here’s what it might look like:

✔ A timely thank-you email with a compelling story of impact

✔ A follow-up update within 10–14 days

✔ A welcome packet (print or digital)

✔ A 30-day impact report or behind-the-scenes video

✔ A 60- or 90-day personal touch, like a phone call, event invite, or short donor survey

Donors who make a second gift within three months are dramatically more likely to give again. That makes your 90-day welcome strategy one of the most effective ways to improve donor retention and turn a one-time gift into long-term support.

❌ Mistake #5: Sending the Same Thank-You to Every Donor

First-time donors are still getting to know your organization, so their first acknowledgment should set the tone for the relationship and help them understand what to expect next.

Returning donors are at a different place in their journey and need reassurance that their continued support is noticed, appreciated, and impactful.

❌ Mistake #6: Not Providing Next Steps

Your thank-you email should provide a clear path forward so new donors won't have to wonder what happens next.

Use your new donor welcome series to set clear expectations and reduce uncertainty. Let donors know:

✔ What happens next

✔ How their gift is already at work

✔ When they’ll hear from you again

✔ Whom to contact with questions

Explaining this process clearly builds donor trust, confidence, and connection.

❌ Mistake #7: Thanking Donors Without Showing Real Impact

“Thanks for helping us deliver better care for all” sounds nice, but it’s too vague to move the needle on donor retention. Show the human impact of their gift by connecting it to a clear, tangible result:

✔ Thanks to your support, Jack, our pediatric therapy dog, eased Lily's anxiety as she and her parents prepared for her surgery.

✔ Because of your generosity, 24-year-old Emily doesn’t have to lose her hair, or her confidence, while battling breast cancer. Your gift provided cold cap therapy; a specialized cooling system that helps prevent hair loss during chemo. For Emily, it meant holding onto her identity and hope during the hardest fight of her life.”

✔ Because you supported our life-saving breast screening technology, Kae’s breast cancer was caught early, when it could be treated. Today, she's enjoying retirement with her husband and inspiring others with her story of hope.

Start Retaining More Donors Today

Don’t wait to improve donor retention, increase second gifts, and build stronger relationships with your donors. Learn smarter ways to engage donors today.

Schedule a free 30-minute strategy session with me today!

We’ll review your donor journey and identify three ways to boost engagement and long-term giving, starting with your donor thank-you messages!

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse